Pattern: Invisible Requirements

Context

Headline:  User Requirements & Models Don’t Tell the Full Story
Kicker: Important dimensions of the problem domain, left undocumented can lead to expensive mistakes and undelivered business outcomes.
Exploring user/stakeholder stories through the five-dimensional lens of the VPEC-T framework surfaces otherwise undocumented change requirements and cross-organizational insights and tensions.
Forces
  • A narrow focus on functional and nonfunctional requirements for the design of business policies, procedures, processes and supporting IT solutions.
  • The assumption that an IT application is the root cause of a problem.
  • The Software is easier to change than structure, policy and culture.
  • Political motivation to avoid dealing with root cause and find a scapegoat (e.g. IT department or IT Service Provider).
Problem
  • The desired business outcomes are not delivered.
  • Wasted time and resources – money.
  • Increased frustration and lack of confidence in policies, documented processes, procedures and IT systems.
  • High impact risks undocumented.
Sketch
VPEC-T Map v.0.5a 30pc.jpeg
Solution
  • Explore user/stakeholder ‘day-in-the-life’ stories using Values, Policies, Events, Content and Trusts dimensions to frame.
  • Start with the Values of all individuals, roles, groups of users, decision makers and other influencing groups, entities, or bodies. These will reflect the motivations and outcomes expected of all participating in, or accountable for, the problem domain.
  • Based on those Values, have Subject Matter Experts describe the Policies, Events and Content in the various ‘Day-in-the-life’ story.
  • Finally, facilitate a cross-party discussion around the Trust dimension; explore the strength and impact of trust relationships and the levels of shared confidence in people, processes, information and technology.
Resulting Context
A holistic understanding of the current state and potential future state, of the problem domain. Improved ability to make informed decisions around; principles, risks, sequence, priorities, policies, processes and technologies. Lowered risk of change project(s) failures.
See also
Rationale (optional)
The VPEC-T framework has been tried-and-tested in many different scenarios; government, banking, logistics, advertising and retail.
Known instances (optional)
U.K. Criminal Justice System, LadbrokesCoral PLC, CLP Power HK Ltd., Royal Mail PLC., The Bank of Ireland, DHL International Ltd.
Status
22  July  2017 – 1st Review-ready draft.
Author
Nigel P.S.Green.

***

Please add any comments and builds to an editable version of this document here.

***
Thanks to the team at InnerSource for the template format and advice on writing design patterns.
***
Comments and suggestions, please.

Links to related posts:

This blog and its contents are freely available for use under

Creative Commons: Attribution + ShareAlike License.

Please follow me on LinkedIn or Twitter for future posts.